Grumpy Butcher Monster Tomahawk Wagyu Steak, 48-60 ounces - Wagyu Beef Dry Aged Ribeye Steak Meat Masterpiece

It was a total impulse buy, but I’m so glad I went for it! Arrived the next day, well packed to stay cold.. I thawed one for dinner and cooked it in a hot skillet with olive oil, using my seasoning. 5 min on one side, 3 on the other and got a perfect crust. Let it rest for a minute, then we split it after a quick discussion on who got which half. It was just perfect. Tender, buttery and full of flavor, just like a high quality NY Strip. We had it with roasted vegetables and a big pot of herbed, buttered mashed potatoes. Honestly, I shouldn’t have second-guessed this purchase. Everything about it was excellent, and I’ll definitely be ordering more!

The steaks were so tender and flavorful; they practically melted in our mouths.

These are truly awful. Restaurant quality? Must be a very low grad restaurant. These are tough, stringy and not acceptable. I was expecting steaks similar to Omaha Steaks in quality, but these are not even remotely close. I expected individually packaged steaks, but no, all in one plastic bag, so they have to be separated. NEVER AGAIN would I buy these, at best they need to be cut up to small pieces and cooked in a slow cooker on low for 9 hours just to make them softer. In my opinion, these are not Prime quality, or even Choice quality, but lower grade quality, so no marbling. Ugh!!

cooked these on grill n they turned out flavorful. is noticeably more succulent than typical grocery store cuts.

Initially, I considered buying Omaha steaks, but I noticed they didn't offer a gift note option. Plus I read several complaints about gift recipients receiving the product receipt (showing the price paid), which didn’t feel ideal for a gift. After going through the reviews, I decided to take a chance on the Grumpy Butcher’s ribeye steaks as a birthday gift for my son, and I’m so glad I did! He was absolutely thrilled. As an avid steak lover who’s been a regular at a well-known local steakhouse for over 35 years, I know my steaks. To my surprise, these Grumpy Butcher ribeyes were nearly a notch above my USDA Prime aged steaks I typically order there for almost $90 each. They were incredibly juicy, flavorful, and tender, exceeding my expectations. Although these ribeyes were aged for less than 45 days (likely around 3-4 weeks), the quality was outstanding. I was so impressed that I’ve already decided to order a 16-pack for myself next time!

This is the first time I have order meat to be delivered. I expected the meat to be frozen upon arrival, but it wasn’t. It was packaged well and did have ice packs. Not sure if it had just thawed from shipping. I haven’t cooked the meat, but for 17$ a strip, it better be dang good! It’s fairly pricey in my opinion, but I am hoping for good quality and tenderness. I doubt at this point, unless the meat is absolutely delicious, I would order meat to be delivered again. I’ll just go to the supermarket and save some money. The meat being thawed upon arrival, just make me nervous. I’m not blaming the seller necessarily and maybe that’s the way it’s supposed to be, or it could have been Amazon letting the package sit too long.

Costly

I received the New York strips package of eight. I was disappointed in the quality of the meat. There was almost no marbling, and consequently almost no flavor. The steaks did not look at all like the pictures on the Amazon webpage. Those steaks are shown as having considerable marbling . These steaks are not prime beef. They are prime Angus beef, which basically means they are ungraded. Will not be ordering from Grumpy again.Even though this item was not returnable, customer service gave me a complete refund.