Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Blendable, Smudge Resistant, Matte Eyeliner For Up To 36HR Wear, Sleepless Sapphire

Love this eyeliner. I use to wear black. But decided to go lighter. Started using thisMaybelline in brown. Waterproof. Goes on smooth. Doesn’t smudge, or flake. Comes off with a couple of wipes with a makeup cleanser or wipe. I have been using Maybelline waterproof eyeliner for many, many years. Love this stuff. You can lighten or darken line. Smudge with sponge on end with cover. Price is great. Who needs expensive makeup from Sephora!!

Best eyeliner I've ever bought. It stays on. Doesn't melt and smear throughout the day. For the most part last all day. I love the thickness and it applies easy. It's really dark without having to reapply several times. LOVE THIS PRODUCT!

My favorite no budget eye liners for waterline and above the eye, no skipping or tugging, goes on effortlessly!!

It stays on all day and is easy to apply

Easy to apply, stays in all day, then comes off easily. It’s waterproof and a mudgeproof it’s a bright blue, not a dark blue. You can tell it from the black the ideal size to put under your on on top of her lash line. To e functionality is great

Finally an eyeliner that stays on. No need to sharpen so you don't waste eyeliner. I really like it.

I am on the hunt to find an eyeliner that doesn’t make me look like a raccoon. I had high hopes for this one. Although she does go on incredibly smooth, a lot of it does stay in place all day, & the color is rich. It does still run and smudge, then once she gets on your skin she’s a beast to remove. So on the hunt I continue.

I LOVE this eyeliner. Smooth. Glides on. Easy to apply and it lasts all day. Nice jet black. No color fade. Great item Great price.Believe it’s waterproof because I have to wash it off. I haven’t “tested “ it